“I wouldn’t go down that alley.”
“I wouldn’t answer that phone.”
“It’s a trap. Run away!”
I love horror movies. Part of the genre’s fun is in imagining what you’d do differently as you watch the characters navigate their world. Of course, we all believe we’d be smarter than at least first victims–we wouldn’t open that door or answer that phone.
But last night, I learned I shouldn’t be quite so confident. I was leaving my improv class. It was late, dark, cold, and rainy. As I unlocked my car, there was a sound. It was just like a car door closing. It came from just a few feet away, but there were no other cars around. The block was deserted.
I looked at the car. I’d been half-distracted, still on some adrenaline from class. So I focused up and tried to replay the sound in my head, wondering whether I’d imagined it. Had someone been crouching behind my car and gotten in? Almost certainly I’d misheard. That I knew. So I got in the car. Still it nagged me.
“Obviously, no one is here. But I may as well check.” Phone flashlight on. Back seats clear. “May as well finish checking.” Out of the car, open the trunk, all clear.
I could see the whole block under the yellow street lamps, there was nothing around, nowhere to lurk. There was only one more place to check–under the car. But now my heart rate was way up. In the horror-movie version, the killer would be lying prone on the street under the car. I knew there was no one, but still I had to psych myself up to look …
… all clear.

The best horror movies create a world in which the character has options, but none of them are good. You the viewer can’t imagine what you’d do differently.
I could have started home, 99.9% sure I had no unwelcome passenger. But probably I’d have arrived home only 99.5%. If I’d still resisted checking once in the garage, I’d have been thinking about it as I lay in bed.
In the moment on the street, I was more embarrassed at myself than I was scared. In the gentle light of day, I’m laughing at myself. I’m replaying it again, enjoying memory like a little movie in my head. But on that empty block, in that yellow light, just a few blocks away from the actual setting of many famous horror-film murders, I wasn’t 0% scared.
